minoanmiss (
minoanmiss) wrote in
agonyaunt2022-02-21 12:51 pm
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Entry tags:
Dear Care & Feeding: My Teen self-diagnosed off of TikTok
Dear Care and Feeding,
My teen is 15 and addicted to TikTok. She used to be much more well adjusted, but once lockdown happened and she was isolated from all of her friends, she became depressed and turned to social media, especially TikTok, to keep her entertained during the boredom and stress of lockdown. Unfortunately, she recently “came out” to us as having dissociative identity disorder. She told us that after she watched some TikTok videos of people who have it, she discovered her own “alter personalities.” From what I understand, this disorder comes from severe childhood abuse, which isn’t true! She had a good childhood, she was always happy and cheerful. She now wants to see a therapist so she can get diagnosed, and looking through her phone, I discovered she has already made a few videos about having DID. I forced her to delete the videos, which was very upsetting to her, and now she is upset that I’m not “validating” her. What do I do? Do I take her to see a therapist, do I call her out on it, or do I just play along?
—Confused and Frustrated
Dear Confused and Frustrated,
TikTok diagnoses are a thing, unfortunately, and it’s not terribly hard to imagine how a young person could get caught up in the idea of having an illness, especially if she is able to see some of her experiences in the stories of people who do have it (or, this being TikTok, people who may believe they have these illnesses regardless of actual diagnosis). I don’t want to completely disregard the possibility that something is going on with your daughter emotionally; while it’s highly likely here that she’s glommed on to the idea of something that isn’t her struggle to bear, she may have made this connection for some valid reasons. As you said, she’s been depressed and isolated from friends. That’s reason enough to seek out therapy services, and while you’re likely to find that she doesn’t have DID, it certainly sounds as though she could benefit from the support of a professional while trying to grapple with the circumstances of the last two years, as well as her feelings regarding what she’s learned online and how she’s processed them thus far. In the meantime, resist disparaging her self-diagnosis and instead focus on letting her know that you are invested in supporting her through anything, that you want to ensure she has the best available resources, and that her health and happiness are both top priorities to you. A therapist can lead the work of divesting from the self-proclaimed DID if necessary; focus on making her feel supported instead.
no subject
Child has asked for a therapist; get her a therapist. That's an easy one.
Parent (1) thinks they have the right to dictate what child puts on TikTok, and (2) hear's child's self-diagnosis and thinks, "Oh, this cannot stand; this is All About Me." Get parent a therapist and some parenting classes.
no subject
no subject
OTOH, that definitely doesn't encompass censoring confessional-style videos on the basis that the parent thinks they are deluded or inaccurate, even if the odds overwhelmingly are that they are inaccurate. If these videos made the parent worry about doxing or future identification of their child that could harm their employment prospects or whatever, that's another issue (and not that unlikely I guess, but I don't know enough about TikTok to judge).
Regardless, even if the parent's real reason was a poorly-expressed fear that the video would harm their child or others now or in the future, the way they're talking about what they did in this letter is giving a very negative impression of their motivations and actions.
no subject
no subject
But yes, if my child is self-diagnosing with some Brain Thing, if I can at all manage it I should get them to an actual brain wrangler; my teen is not qualified to diagnose a Brain Thing, but they're 100% qualified to say "hey, something's going on in my head that doesn't seem right".
no subject
If all, all that's going on is that LW's kid is looking for attention and belonging, a therapist can help her sort that out. Just...this is the easy part, you know?
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
And they clearly realize from the letter that the kid's reaction to this identity is, itself, a problem, and a sign of underlying struggles, but they aren't able to make the tremendous leap from there to the idea of a therapist, even though the kid brought it up?!
It kind of sounds like this parent is one of those people who doesn't really "believe in" therapy, but it's been a whole generation since I dealt with that problem in my parents; it seems a lot less likely today.
no subject
It depends on the parents background - I read a blog post on a feminist/antiracist blog in 2010 by two Asian women in their mid-to-late-twenties talking about how their parents were deeply anti-therapy, and how this was still unfortunately common for many Asian parents in 2010.
no subject
no subject
no subject
no subject
And my second reaction was "take her to a therapist and understand that her therapy is for her, not for you."
with a garnish of wanting to dope slap this parent.
no subject
no subject
I am dubious of a lot of the literature about DID, but many of the classic cases were kids who were apparently severely abused in ways their parents never knew about, so even the parents haven't witnessed or been involved in serious abuse, that's not really an answer.
no subject
I dissociated like hell.
Did it rise to the level of full-blown DID? I have no idea, but my main means of dealing with the depression that hit me like a bowling ball to the stomach when my hormones fucked me up and gave me menstruation was that one of me kept the worst of the symptoms from the rest of me, and when I was in my early 20s I got basically roommates counseling between various aspects.
Kid needs a therapist yesterday.
no subject
(I don't think it's generally in kids' best interest to have videos/photos online but I understand I am very square & also this is why I'm not a parent; certainly I engaged in online behavior as a teen that would have horrified my parents... Though I'm also grateful it's not tied to my face/name because, of course, it was super cringey)
no subject
How is one to deal with strange things on the internet? Dissociative identity disorder among social media users at scepticism-inducing proportions, being 'kin' to a fictional character and feel you really are the character, believing you're the reincarnation of a historical figure, being 'otherkin' and identifying as an animal ... My preferred approach is to treat people with respect and honour reasonable requests. If someone has a strong belief that seems mildly silly to you (and examples of 'belief that can seem a bit silly' include most religions), the point to address it with them is either when they ask for your thoughts or if the belief causes them to behave in a way that hurts or seriously inconveniences you.
no subject
By which I mean, if you're not familiar with the phenomenon, it is indeed very popular with kids on the internet these days to claim that they are literally multiple fictional characters and that this is DID. It's mainly used to harass other people online for shipping the wrong things or not liking their favorite character. I feel sorry for their parents if they try to take it out of online spaces. They're just dumb kids and should not be taken seriously.
no subject
In my day they would have just outright said they were channeling a fictional character or married to Snape on astral plane, but parts of tiktok in particular have learned to coopt the language of psychology and disability for this kind of thing.
But most of the people who think they're kin with anime characters to the extent they're falling into those communities need a therapist anyway, so: this kid wants a therapist, get them one if you can. And also get them enough training on internet safety to make sure they aren't falling into something dangerously cultlike online, although hopefully a good therapist will be able to help with that too.