minoanmiss: Naked young fisherman with his catch (Minoan Fisherman)
minoanmiss ([personal profile] minoanmiss) wrote in [community profile] agonyaunt2020-04-21 06:35 pm

Dear Care & Feeding: Trapped With Homophobic Parents

Dear Care and Feeding,

I’m 14 years old, and my parents just found out I’m gay. My mom was listening at my door when I was Zooming with my boyfriend. She heard me tell him that I love him. So now I’m trapped with my parents who are telling me that being gay is disgusting and an insult to a god I don’t even believe in. I knew coming out to them would be hard, but I didn’t expect to be trapped with them after it happened. I feel like you guys give good, levelheaded advice, and honestly I wish you were my parents instead. Do you have any advice on getting through the next couple of months without me going crazy?

—Trapped


Dear Trapped,

I’m sorry this didn’t go as you’d planned. Under normal circumstances I would urge you to connect with any adult you love and trust—an aunt or uncle, a teacher or minister, a neighbor or friend—but these are not normal circumstances, and none of those people are available to you immediately. I think the safest thing at the moment would be to negotiate some kind of peace with your parents; you are indeed trapped with them for the time being.

It is not impossible that, despite what they’re saying now, your parents will someday be fiercely supportive of who you are. I really hope you get there! But I don’t want you to think about that at the moment. It is your parents’ job to love you unconditionally. It is not your job to argue for your own worth.

I hope your folks are still doing some of their job—feeding you, caring for you—and if they are, I hope you can remember that those things are also an expression of their love. (They could be doing more! But maybe this is all they can do right now.) As long as you are safe at home, I think you should try to just endure this moment.

If you feel unsafe—like they talk about asking you to leave your home or threaten you physically—that is another matter. That would be an emergency, and if that comes up, you should reach out to one of the adults you trust or, if that’s not an option, to an organization for young people like you.

But maybe you just feel bad and frustrated—you are who you are, your parents do not respect that. As terrible as that certainly is, I’m worried only about you surviving this weird period of quarantine. I don’t think you should lie or pretend to be anything you’re not.

If your parents bring up the subject of your being gay, try to change it. If they tell you it is disgusting, tell them that is cruel, and you don’t want to discuss being gay in these terms. None of this is how this should work, and I wish I had better advice, but I just want you to get through this moment. I want you to wait to have the hard conversations with your folks until you have some support from other people in your life.

To that end, I think you should preserve your connections to those other people—not just video chatting your boyfriend, but emailing and calling other friends, so you can remind yourself that while you’re stuck at home with Mom and Dad, there are still a lot of people out in the world whom you’re connected to. Throw yourself into your schoolwork, stay connected to your social network, be strong, be safe, and know that a lot of people out there (me included!) want you to be well. Please email me again if you need to talk.
likeaduck: Cristina from Grey's Anatomy runs towards the hospital as dawn breaks, carrying her motorcycle helmet. (Default)

[personal profile] likeaduck 2020-04-22 05:59 pm (UTC)(link)
Yes! And there's way more the columnist could have done in terms of describing a standard they expect parents to meet that's higher than "feed and clothe and don't hit".
colorwheel: brideshead revisited: charles & sebastian in venice with an umbrella (charles & sebastian in venice)

[personal profile] colorwheel 2020-04-21 11:02 pm (UTC)(link)
Under normal circumstances I would urge you to connect with any adult you love and trust—an aunt or uncle, a teacher or minister, a neighbor or friend—but these are not normal circumstances, and none of those people are available to you immediately.

not just video chatting your boyfriend, but emailing and calling other friends


i'm a bit confused -- i don't understand why calling, emailing, or videochatting with any of those other trusted adults seems to be off the table, and why, when the columnist tells the LW to be in touch with others outside of the house, it seems to be narrowed down to friends, which i'm reading as peers. i'm not saying the LW necessarily has the necessary info to be able to reach any trusted/trustworthy adults (if he has any, which, i HOPE he does), but he might? why isn't that a suggestion here?
ashbet: (Default)

[personal profile] ashbet 2020-04-21 11:14 pm (UTC)(link)
I agree, that confused me, too.

My heart breaks for this poor kid :(
julian: Picture of the sign for Julian Street. (Default)

[personal profile] julian 2020-04-22 12:00 am (UTC)(link)
I think there was an unspoken "connecting in person with any adult" bit there.

But totally like, connect with them in all those other ways, TOO, LW & columnist.
likeaduck: Cristina from Grey's Anatomy runs towards the hospital as dawn breaks, carrying her motorcycle helmet. (Default)

[personal profile] likeaduck 2020-04-22 01:30 pm (UTC)(link)
THIS.

Or even a helpline? Or a suggestion to see if a local queer support org has phone/video/text supports available? Like, some of my references are Canadian (but also when texting a helpline does it matter where you are?) but: LGBT Youth Line (2slgbtq youth peer support); Kids Help Phone Crisis Text Line; The Trevor Project...

I feel like this is what happens when the advice columnist is seeing things from the perspective of parents and not the youth writing in.
Edited 2020-04-22 13:32 (UTC)
likeaduck: Cristina from Grey's Anatomy runs towards the hospital as dawn breaks, carrying her motorcycle helmet. (Default)

[personal profile] likeaduck 2020-04-22 01:46 pm (UTC)(link)
Also, the way the columnist avoids saying the word gay or any other specific words about queerness--except to say to change the subject and not talk about it--really rubs me the wrong way.
cereta: Holtlzmann from Ghostbusters (blond woman with wacky goggleson her head) looking pensive (Holtzmann)

[personal profile] cereta 2020-04-21 11:58 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, geez, kid, can you make it to East Central IL? Quarantine complicates everything, but if there ARE any adults with both the willingness and standing to do something, whether open their home or just be there for video chats, please, LW, reach out.

I think it's easy for adults to forget just how not-safe home can feel to kids, even under the mildest of circumstances. There was never, in my whole childhood, a place I could go that could not be invaded, by parents, sibling, grandparents. Nothing was safe, and nothing was sacred, and I didn't have any issues more serious than being the family weirdo. I can't imagine the kind of hell this quarantine would have been even then.
ysobel: A man wielding a kitchen knife and making an adorable yelling face (rage)

[personal profile] ysobel 2020-04-22 12:23 am (UTC)(link)
Or California. I don't even particularly want another person dependent on me and I still want to take him in.
lemonsharks: (wedding shit)

[personal profile] lemonsharks 2020-04-22 02:12 am (UTC)(link)
Same, and I don't even have a job. I want desperately to have him be able to zoom his boyfriend while his guardian zooms their partner in the other room, before sitting down to sourdough pizza and some stupid fun gay show on TV.
kelly_holden: Rainbow map of Australia. Text: "The critters aren't the only queer things here. Australian, Lesbian and proud." (RainbowOz)

[personal profile] kelly_holden 2020-04-22 09:38 am (UTC)(link)
poor baby
mommy: Wanda Maximoff; Scarlet Witch (Default)

[personal profile] mommy 2020-04-22 01:25 pm (UTC)(link)
It seems like this columnist has little idea of how dangerous it is to be a queer kid under the thumb of homophobic adults who already know you aren't straight. The best case scenario isn't "just feel bad and frustrated," because that ship sailed the second they found out. By definition, this has already crossed into unsafe territory.
lemonsharks: (Default)

[personal profile] lemonsharks 2020-04-22 04:35 pm (UTC)(link)
also WOW, every single letter writer in this week's column is in an awful way and I want to bring them all to a workshare commune where we get to do things we love with people who care about us and equitably share things like chores and childminding duties.

Kiddo from this letter's boyfriend is welcome to come too, though they'd both be getting The Talk before room-sharing.
rosefox: Green books on library shelves. (Default)

[personal profile] rosefox 2020-04-23 05:46 pm (UTC)(link)
I wish this kid had written to Ask Papí instead. This is awful advice.
melissatreglia: (forever knight (nick) - what did I read?)

[personal profile] melissatreglia 2020-05-04 04:49 am (UTC)(link)
OOF, this poor kid. C&F wasn't very kind to them with the response.

Seriously, for LGBT+ kids with homophobic parents, they are in a dangerous and precarious situation. Yelling about how "disgusting and sinful" they supposedly are is just the tip of the iceberg (though that's horrible enough on its own!).

This kid could be in real danger, right now. And the columnist failed to address that.

If LW's boyfriend is out and has a support system, he may actually be able to get LW to safety. LW needs their boyfriend -- and their online "family"/friends -- more than ever now.